Search This Blog

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

"Dixie" and The Pride Band. My rant

Any of my friends who know me really really well, should understand that I grew up in a podunk little town that was filled with racist people. I had a total of MAYBE 6 black people in a high school of 1,000+. It wasn't until I came to college that I really got introduced to working side by side with black people. 
I am not racist. Nor do I condone it. Nor does my family. But something I don't understand is that we are all people. We are all God's children and I don't understand why some people can't just accept that. HOWEVER, if someone is so deeply rooted in their beliefs that in 2011/2012 they still feel that way...you WILL not change their minds. No amount of persuasion or argumentation will get them to accept that these things that they have believed all their life is wrong and that suddenly YOU are right. But I digress,

Most of my friends know how stirred up this has gotten me. It absolutely infuriated me the second I saw it on Mr. Casey's facebook wall. Then I started reading article after article after article. Most of them said basically the same thing. Here's a link to one that really got me going: http://stlouis.cbslocal.com/2011/12/17/dixie-banned-from-m-s-u-band-playbook/#.Tu7E4Ied8R0.facebook

In fact here's a status of mine that blew up: 
Ashlee Nicole Fergen
December 19, 2011

Pride band BANNED from playing "dixie" in public ever again??? Seriously? Is this what our world has come to? *censorship* ............ O.o
Like ·  · Share

  • Kayla Dawn Presley, Kayla Slagle and 9 others like this.


    • Kayla Pieczynski whaaaat?...is this true? I need details lol
      December 19, 2011 at 12:25am · Like ·  1

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen http://stlouis.cbslocal.com/2011/12/17/dixie-banned-from-m-s-u-band-playbook/#.Tu7E4Ied8R0.facebook

      “Dixie” Banned From M.S.U. Band Playbook
      stlouis.cbslocal.com
      Missouri State University's interim president has apologized for the school's Pr...See More
      December 19, 2011 at 12:30am · Like · 


    • Phil Scott This is not even okay, not in a single way. I fear for what this is going to do to Hoover.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:33am · Unlike ·  2


    • Kayla Pieczynski ooook then lol Because Hoover is such an offensive man! lol Like a college band REALLY meant to offend people with a song...I mean come on.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:33am · Like


    • Phil Scott This is just the first step. Next Forget You is gonna go because of it's "other version". Then the Time Warp will be gone from bball games because the Rocky Horror Picture Show features a sweet transvestite as a star. Then the fight song will be gone thanks to angry Scots. Not okay.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:35am · Like ·  4

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen I know...I'm very sad and annoyed at this. I do not believe that Hoover meant to offend anyone with this song...it's a song...
      December 19, 2011 at 12:36am · Like ·  1


    • Connie Reinhardt Hoov didn't mean it maliciously i'm sure, this is also kind of a knee jerk reaction and yes it was an inappropriate choice but overall i wasn't meant to be offensive.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:36am · Like


    • Connie Reinhardt exactly, which in some locals can stir patriotic feeling and i bet that is what Hoov was going, for and didn't expect this
      December 19, 2011 at 12:39am · Like


    • Delete CommentMark as Spam
      Roger Payne By complaints they meant the local newspaper twist the shit out of a story and let the NAACP get upset.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:52am · Like


    • Jena Marie You've. GOT. to. be. KIDDING. me.
      December 19, 2011 at 12:57am · Like


    • Andrew Tiefenbrunn well guys this is unfortunate, but everyone has the right to their opinion no matter how skewed it may be. Yes Dixie was a southern song, but it is a huge part of our history. But it is a part that is still a little bit touchy, I do have to say that the lynching part of the article seems a little bit over the top on the opposing side. There are not to many people in Springfield who know about it blacks and whites equally.
      December 19, 2011 at 2:18am · Like


    • Brooke Guichet What the hell! Thats not cool at all.
      December 19, 2011 at 2:55am · Unlike ·  1


    • Bryan Smith Blasphemy!!
      December 19, 2011 at 6:01am · Unlike ·  1


    • Quentin Coggin I thought it was ironic. The article that I read from the Springfield News Leader seemed to be written by a veteran (he was wearing a hat). If he only new the amount of dedication and commitment that Mr. Hoover has for veterans, with the amount of Memorial Day performances, etc. He is one of the most patriotic people that I've ever met, and he idolizes Lincoln, so it's only fitting that he wanted to play "Dixie." I just think it's sad for such a good man who meant no ill will toward anyone to have to endure this.
      December 19, 2011 at 7:19am · Unlike ·  5


    • Jesse Lytle Guess we live in a world where whatever offends people we have to ban it. Shame on those who twist the truth.
      December 19, 2011 at 9:51am · Like ·  1


    • Andrew Medley I think this article paints a worst picture than that one, saying that we lack cultural competence, what a joke, if you havent done ur hw, then no one should have been upset. Its more like everyone else who is complaining is culturally incompetent.
      December 19, 2011 at 10:09am · Like


    • Andrew Medley http://www.news-leader.com/article/20111217/NEWS01/112170375/MSU-band-Dixie-square

      MSU leader apologizes for band playing 'Dixie'
      www.News-Leader.com
      MSU Interim President Clif Smart said the school's Pride Band made an 'unfortuna...See More
      December 19, 2011 at 10:09am · Like · 


    • Elaina Blumenkraft Winstar music is not insensitive.
      December 19, 2011 at 10:18am · Like


    • Andrew Medley that was another thing that got me, music is not insensitive, just how people percieve it, and it only comes from a lack of knowledge about the piece
      December 19, 2011 at 10:20am · Unlike ·  1


    • Caitlyn Alice Chism Well, the NAACP can eat shit. I'm usually the first one to stand up for civil rights and what they have done for the african american population, however, Dixie is a huge part of our history. So are we supposed to pretend that that part of American history didn't happen to make black people feel better. If that's the case, then we should get rid of every other march ever made. I don't like the way they were treated any more than the next black dude, but sorry, their sorrows are a major part of history. If they wanted us to play Follow the damn Drinking Gourd, we can! So I say next season we play the old sea shanty Blow the Man Down as a screw you!!
      December 19, 2011 at 10:43am · Unlike ·  3


    • Caitlyn Alice Chism ‎"Those who do not remember the past are condemed to repeat it". I will let them know that Amazing Grace was considered sacreligious when it was first written?? Now it's in almost every hymnal!
      December 19, 2011 at 10:55am · Like

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen ‎"I'm glad it was noted," Coopwood said. "Everyone involved has the opportunity to understand how music can be used in a way that is insensitive." SERIOUSLY??? maybe we should talk about how music is interpreted or force some of our administration to sit through a world music or music appreciation class, so they understand that music isn't meant any certain way. It's all based on the way people interpret it.
      December 19, 2011 at 11:15am · Like ·  1


    • Caitlyn Alice Chism fact
      December 19, 2011 at 11:16am · Unlike ·  1

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen They keep saying it was an "Unfortunate choice" but I would be willing to bet if the NAACP hadn't caught wind of the story our administration wouldn't have ever realized the connection either...let's not make Hoover look like an unintelligent man. And don't be apologizing on his behalf.
      December 19, 2011 at 11:17am · Like ·  2

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen Quote from someone on this topic on someone else's status where they are against Hoover and his decision: Eric Speake "So what exactly were they dedicating? If it has nothing to do with the lynchings that happened on the square then I guess I don;t get it. By that type of logic all public performances of the some "Dixie" should be banned and teh NAACP should be looking for every band that plays it in public and demand an appology.

      Now if they were dedicating something in memory of the incident then a different song could have been used. The song has a very interesting history and was around before the civil war and was a fovorite of President Abraham Lincoln. The last I checked he was against slavery. And from what I have read from the history of the song it was written more about the longning of circus performers looking to return to the warmer South in the winter months.

      So over the past almost 160 years the song could have been misinterpreted abd through that interpretation believed to be a slave song. THere is a huge controversy as to whom the actual auther is as well. I think it's time that we all just thicken our skin a little. If I went around everytime someone did something I disagreed with I would lose a lot of sleep and a lot of productivity. Take from someone that has faced strereotypes his entire life. Because you know fat people are lazy stupid people and they could never be as successful as the skinny people in the world. At least I'm not short. :)"
      11 hours ago · Unlike · 2
      December 19, 2011 at 11:26am · Like

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen ‎Jesse...what does this have to do with this...lol
      December 19, 2011 at 11:29am · Like


    • Jesse Lytle Reverse Racism is all I'm getting at. People get offended to easily. If the African-American community can say the word, but if a white person uses it in the same context as a African-American its racist.
      December 19, 2011 at 11:32am · Like

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen gotcha I see it
      December 19, 2011 at 11:34am · Like


    • Sara Friga when I saw that I was shocked,that is stupid that they are banning it.
      December 19, 2011 at 2:18pm · Like


    • Mackenzie Alta Farris Gosh, guys. I'm not sure that the Pride Band segment can be aired on America's Got Talent. I mean, the song Dynamite mentions dancing and although it was the instrumental version, some people are extremely offended by such activities.
      December 19, 2011 at 3:01pm · Like ·  2


    • Kayla Dawn Presley This is ridiculous. Might as well not play any songs in public that have historic meaning because we'll always offend somebody. Oh, and I bet Hoover didn't apologize knowing him.
      December 19, 2011 at 7:11pm · Like

    • Ashlee Nicole Fergen He didn't
      December 19, 2011 at 7:51pm · Like ·  1


    • Daron Coggin ‎:)
      December 19, 2011 at 10:11pm · Unlike ·  1
This, frustrates me to all heck..."The Missouri State University  band director, Jerry Hoover, has apologized and says he had failed to see the connection between the music and the lynchings."

1. He did not apologize. Or had not at this time. Clif Smart apologized for him. 
2. Mr. Hoover does understand the significance of the song. The real one.
3. What connection? The dedication wasn't in honor of the lynchings...

After reading several articles and comments about this topic I've decided I will say here what I feel rather than blurbing all over the internet and getting myself in trouble.

Here are some of the comments I ran across. 830 comments on 1 article on the huffingtonpust.com These are just from the first page:

I'm a raised Back-Mountian Parts and i know what the message was.
The band director knew what he was asking his band to play was just wrong. I grew up isolated from colored people and being from parts where racsist behavior was common. Sad to say, my kin is Klan and it hurts as i reject their belief as inhumane as we are all one race HUMAN.
I speak the truth that the director knew that selection was offensive and was played with intent.
I was acepted to several school including Missouri, and I'm proud I declined because I would be packing to leave for a new school right now.

Band director didn't know the significan­ce of the song....hm­mmmm....an
other attempt of a person being caught exhibiting what can be deemed as racist behavior and then trying the denial card (see Rihanna article)

Dixie isn't a racist song. It's a song about someone pining for their home.

The assertion that Dixie is a racist song is a stretch, to say the least.

1 the song Dixie has many differing versions some Pro Confederat­e, some Pro Union. Who is the NAACP to determine what is and is not offensive? Oh and a lynching that happened in the 1900's has NOTHING to do with the Confederacy.


MY RESPONSE:

Mr. Hoover is THE most patriotic person you will ever meet. We have black students in the band and he loves every single one of his students. He doesn't see color. He knows what the song means. The problem is the general public doesn't know the history of the song or it's significance. The square was being dedicated after having been under construction for about 2 years. It had nothing to do in relation to the lynchings. There's no reason why this song should even be an issue. People need to learn everything they can about something before they go around complaining. If you truly understand music and what it means and how it's interpreted, then speak. Maybe it wasn't the best decision, but there was no malice or ill intent here. 'Dixie' stirs up patriotism in most and that is what the intent was. People need to let this go. Mistakes are made. We live. We learn. Life goes on. No use banning music and getting all worked up over something. Apology was made, move on.

P.S. I also rather enjoy comments like: "I speak the truth", "I know for certain/fact/sure" speaking of Mr. Hoover's intentions and knowledge...

My Response:

I am SO very happy that you all KNOW what his intentions were. It's so relieving to finally have people who are inside Mr. Hoover's mind explaining every move he makes, every step he takes, every word he speaks, and every prayer he prays.

This pretty much sums up my feelings about the song itself: 

“Or maybe it's just a beautiful song of historical significance. Banning it from being played as a little bit like book burning. History should be learned, not shunned.”

No comments:

Post a Comment